A website that just “exists” usually works like a digital business card, and it rarely brings consistent leads. The fix is giving your site a job: guide people from interest to a clear next step.
By:
Devin Blandino
Last Updated:
If you have ever asked what your website should do, start with this: it should turn curiosity into action. A site that only sits online is not broken, but it is usually not working.
Here’s why that leads to frustration. People don’t calmly read your pages like a brochure. They scan, they judge, and they bounce. Nielsen Norman Group research has found most users scan pages, and they often read only a small portion of the words during a visit.
On mobile, the bar is even higher. Google has reported that over half of mobile visits are abandoned if a page takes longer than about three seconds to load. (Google, n.d.).
So if your site is just “about you” and a few pretty photos, it may still be failing at the real moment that matters: the moment someone is deciding whether you are legit.
1. Can a stranger answer these in under 10 seconds, just by scanning?
2. Do you have exactly one primary CTA above the fold (the part visible before scrolling), like “Book a consult” or “Get a quote”? If you have three equal buttons, you are splitting attention.
3. Does your site load fast on a phone over cell service?
4. Is your proof obvious? Reviews, outcomes, before and after, real photos, or clear credentials.
5. Does each key page end with a next step that matches the visitor’s intent, not yours?
The myth says: “If I have a website, I’m covered.” The truth is: a website without a path is like a store with no signs, no cashier, and no hours posted. People walk in, feel unsure, and leave. This matters because your best leads are often the ones who are already interested. They just need clarity and confidence.
A useful way to think about it is “decision friction.” Decision friction is anything that makes it harder for someone to decide to contact you. Long paragraphs, vague buttons, missing pricing ranges, and slow pages all add friction. In plain English: if they have to guess, they will quit.
Credibility is a huge part of this. Stanford’s web credibility research found many people rely heavily on design cues when judging credibility.
Q: What’s the difference between a website and a lead generator?
A: A website is just a place. A lead generator is a place with a clear offer, proof, and a single next step tied to what the visitor wants right now.
Q: Do I really need a CTA on every page?
A: If the page has business value, yes. Just make the CTA match the page’s purpose. “Get started” is often too vague, while “See pricing” or “Request a quote” is clearer.
If you run a local service business, like a tattoo studio, a cleaning company, or a private trainer, your visitor usually arrives with one question: “Can you help me, and are you trustworthy?”
Before: the site opens with a big hero image and a vague tagline. The menu has seven items. The only contact option is a tiny link in the footer. That’s a digital business card. It exists, but it does not guide.
After: the hero says what you do, who it’s for, and the outcome. Right next to it is one button: “Request availability” or “Get a quote.” Under that is proof: photos, reviews, and a short “how it works.” The page is lighter, faster, and easier to scan. Users scan pages quickly, so the structure does the heavy lifting.
When you fix this, it unlocks a simple win: the people who already found you finally know what to do next.
The biggest shift is that your site stops being “a place people can look you up” and becomes “a place that closes the gap between interest and action.” This connects back to the problem we started with. Most owners are not short on exposure, they are short on conversion.
Search engine optimization (SEO) means improving your site so it shows up when people search. Even when you do that, page experience still matters because it affects real humans on the page, and Google explicitly recommends strong real-world user experience signals like Core Web Vitals.
Said another way: traffic is rented attention. A clear path is what makes that attention pay you back.
1. Build a “decision path” by intent:
2. Add proof that matches risk: guarantees, process transparency, policies, and real work examples. Stanford’s work shows credibility signals can be decisive.
3. Make a light analytics plan so you can see leak points: which pages get views, which CTAs get clicks, and where people drop off. That’s why the next step is measuring, not guessing.
Your website should not just sit online. It should guide someone from “I might need this” to “I know what to do next.”
The most common mistake is treating the homepage like a brochure, then hiding the action step in the menu or footer. In plain English: people do not know where to go, so they leave.
The single best first step is to choose one primary call to action (CTA) and make it obvious on the homepage, paired with one clear line that explains who you help and what result they get. When you fix this, it unlocks everything else because your traffic finally has a path.
Sources you can trust and cite:
